(Menon, 2011)
Summary:
Conceptual Framework:
The paper proposes a "Triple Network Model" centered on three core neurocognitive networks:
- Central Executive Network (CEN):
- Anchored in dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (dlPFC) and posterior parietal cortex (PPC)
- Responsible for working memory, attention, and executive control
- Default Mode Network (DMN):
- Anchored in posterior cingulate cortex (PCC) and medial prefrontal cortex (mPFC)
- Important for self-referential mental activity, autobiographical memory
- Salience Network (SN):
- Anchored in dorsal anterior cingulate cortex (dACC) and frontoinsular cortex (FIC)
- Critical for detecting and orienting to salient external stimuli and internal events
- Includes subcortical nodes: amygdala and substantia nigra/ventral tegmental area
Analytical Approaches Reviewed:
1. Graph-Theoretical Analysis:
- Network metrics: clustering coefficient, path length, degree, centrality
- Small-world architecture analysis
- Hub identification
- Used to characterize topology, modularity, and hierarchy of whole-brain networks
2. Intrinsic Connectivity Network (ICN) Analysis:
- Based on resting-state fMRI (rfMRI)
- Independent Component Analysis (ICA) to identify networks
- Functional connectivity analysis (temporal correlation of BOLD signals)
- Task-free connectivity patterns
3. Structural Connectivity:
- Diffusion Tensor Imaging (DTI) for white matter tract integrity
- Tract-tracing to measure anatomical pathways
Key Methodological Principles Discussed:
- Node-level analysis:
- Cytoarchitectonic mapping
- Neurochemical receptor mapping
- Regional gray matter changes
- Local circuit dysfunction
- Edge-level analysis:
- Functional connectivity (statistical correlation between regions)
- Structural connectivity (physical white matter pathways)
- Effective connectivity (directional influences)
- Network-level metrics:
- Out-degree/in-degree
- Path length
- Clustering coefficient
- Module identification
- Identification of dysfunctional hubs
Triple Network Model Predictions:
The model proposes that aberrant salience detection and mapping by the SN leads to:
- Impaired engagement/disengagement of the CEN
- Abnormal regulation of the DMN
- Cascade effects on cognition and behavior across multiple disorders
Key Mechanisms of Dysfunction:
- Weak salience mapping from sensory, limbic, and self-referential inputs
- Impaired SN signaling to CEN and DMN
- Altered anterior-posterior insula interactions
- Disrupted ACC-mediated access to motor systems
- Compensatory network reorganization
Clinical Applications Discussed:
- Disease-specific network signatures
- Biomarker development for differential diagnosis
- Understanding symptom heterogeneity within disorders
- Identifying convergent/divergent patterns across disorders
- Potential for targeted interventions
Summary:
This review synthesizes research using graph-theoretical and intrinsic connectivity approaches to understand how dysfunction in three core brain networks (SN, CEN, DMN) contributes to psychopathology. The triple network model emphasizes the SN's role in detecting salience and orchestrating engagement of the CEN and disengagement of the DMN. The review demonstrates surprising parallels in network dysfunction across diverse psychiatric and neurological disorders, suggesting common underlying mechanisms despite different symptom profiles.
